Research Guides: Research in Education : Is it Peer Reviewed?

Checking for Peer-Review - Three Options

Here are three methods for the checking peer-reviewed (refereed) status of a journal:

OneSearch - easiest method if you have the title of an article
UlrichsWeb - most comprehensive list of journals (currently only works on campus) (must have journal name)
Scholar's Portal - if you're off campus and you only have the name of the journal

About Peer Review and Databases that limit to Peer-Reviewed Journals

Peer-Review Check - Option #1 - OneSearch (library website)

OneSearch
This method works if you have the title of an article.

Paste the title of the article in the search blank (ONESEARCH) on the library website.

If the journal that this article was published in a blue icon and PEER REVIEWED label will appear in the results.

If your article doesn't appear in the OneSearch results -
which will happen if we don't subscribe to the journal -
you can still generate a OneSearch record by clicking on
the option Expand My Results -
found on the right-hand side of the results page.

Peer-Review Check - Option #2 - "UlrichsWeb"

UlrichsWeb (checking to see if a journal is refereed or peer-reviewed)
Type the name of the journal or a field of interest into UlrichsWeb.

If the journal has a "black book" icon (or referee icon) in the third column it IS refereed (or peer reviewed).

For instance if I search for journals with the words "special education" in the title UlrichsWeb indicates that:

Rural Special Education Quarterly is refereed (it is peer reviewed)

Advances in Special Education is not

Special Education in Canada is not

WARNING the Black Book Icon (or referee icon) is the icon to watch for when determining if a journal is peer-reviewed (refereed). Do not pay any attention to the gold stars (which are labeled "reviewed" ... but in this case that just means the journal was "reviewed" by a librarian for UlrichsWeb ... it does NOT mean that the journal is "peer reviewed").

You can also click on the title of the entry - e.g. Rural Special Education Quarterly - and then click on the option "Additional Title Details" which will also confirm that the journal is indeed "peer reviewed".

Peer-Review Check - Option #3 - "Scholar's Portal"

Scholar's Portal - Peer Review Check for Journals
This open access database created by the Canadian Center for Research Libraries and the Ontario Council of University Libraries can be used in lieu of Ulrich's Web (which hasn't been working off campus).

Scroll down to page to the "white colored" section of the page - to the search blank Find Journals / By Title. Type in the name of your journal. Then scroll down through the search results to find your journal. Peer-review is indicated by a bold hard-to-miss black-and-white box. Not all journals listed in Scholar's Portal are peer-reviewed - watch for the presence or absence of that black-and-white peer-reviewed label.

More about Scholar's Portal

About Peer Review and Databases that limit to Peer-Reviewed Journals

To maintain high levels of quality and reliability, the most respected and dependable journals in Education require all manuscripts (potential articles) to be reviewed by other experts (peers) to determine whether the submitted scholarship meets the high standards of the journal.

This process is called peer review and journals that utilize peer review are often referred to as refereed journals.

To be sure you are using the highest quality research and scholarship in your projects you should gather your materials from peer reviewed journals / refereed journals

How can you be sure you are working with a peer-reviewed journal?

When searching EBSCO databases such as ERIC or APA PsycInfo be sure to check the box for "Scholarly (Peer Reviewed) Journals" found farther down the search page before completing your search:

Scholarly or peer reviewed or refereed journal option for EBSCO databases such as ERIC and APA PsycInfo

When searching OneSearch you can limit your results after you search by clicking on the "Peer-reviewed Journals" option found on the right-hand column of the results page:

The Peer-reviewed Journal option in OneSearch (the Rod Library search engine)

However, you might find an article using Google Scholar or from a reference list (snowball backward) or using the cited by option in Google Scholar (snowball forward). Since you can't limit to peer-reviewed journals with these techniques you need to use either the database UlrichsWeb or the Scholar's Portal to determine if the journal that published your article was refereed (peer-reviewed).